As always, I wrote multiple stories for the NYC midnight competition. This was the story I’d been going to submit, until I wrote the one I actually submitted (on the Thursday night prior to the Saturday night deadline). It’s not a bad story, but it didn’t really feel like me.
Perhaps it’s the better story for it…
Best Date Night Ever
He looks… kinda like his picture?
Except, well… shorter.
And … greasier.
And he’s wearing chewed-up khaki cargo shorts and flip flops. In January. In Chicago.
To be fair, it’s not like his picture showed what he was wearing, but… really? Flip flops in January? In 15 degree weather?
I bite back the internal monologue and paste a smile on my face.
This could work.
He could be brilliant and kind and funny.
Or he could be a weirdo wearing flip flops in January.
Still, I smile, and stand up from the table where I’ve been waiting twenty minutes for him to show up.
He picked the restaurant, so you’d think he’d know where it is.
Sigh.
I brush non-existent crumbs off of my favorite sweater dress, stand up on the impractically high heels I wore tonight and extend a hand. The heels will hurt like hell if I stand on them for more than five minutes, but…. Look at them. They’re so cute, aren’t they?
I digress.
He takes my hand with all the enthusiasm of someone being given a cold mackerel.
“Hi,” I say.
“Hello,” he says, as he looks me up and down.
“You looked thinner in your photos,” he says. “That’s ok, though. I’m ok with chubby chicks.”
Ugh.
No.
No ugh.
I’m hopeful.
Well, maybe I’m not hopeful, but my Mom is hopeful, so I’m hopeful for her, if that makes any sense.
I believe that life particularly likes to kick you when you’re down.
After all, life kicked me all the way from California to Chicago, when my Environmental Science degree with a minor in Marine Biology got me zero job opportunities, and the professor I’d been working for had his grant rescinded, which in turn, rescinded my paycheck, which caused me to lose my apartment, which caused me to move here, to live with my mother and work as a waitress, and which, ultimately, led me here, to this very fancy restaurant that I couldn’t afford in my wildest dreams, and this dude, who I met on a dating app.
As with so many things, it seemed like a good idea at the time.
And as with so many other things, my mother encouraged me to do it.
I wouldn’t have even downloaded the stupid app, if it weren’t for my stupid Dad. Apparently, my college graduation caused him to realize that had not yet done what he wanted to do with his life. And that realization included the fact that my mother was no longer on his to-do list.
So now, he’s living on a kibbutz in Israel, stomping grapes and smoking pot, and I’m in Chicago, accompanying my Mother in the grand, horrifying adventures of online dating.
Let’s do it together, she said.
It’ll be fun, she said.
My mother approached this new venture with her customary boundless optimism.
And, looking at this guy, I hoped to borrow just a little of that optimism tonight.
His picture was cute.
He appeared to be able to formulate complete sentences, punctuation and all.
He appeared sane, and employed and … well, normal. And at this point, that was good enough for me.
And when he chose this restaurant, I was hopeful. Because you don’t take someone to a special place if you don’t think they’re special, do you?
I shake off my misgivings and try to focus on the, erm, gentleman sitting in front of me.
“So, how was your day?” I ask, diplomatically. “Busy at work?”
“Haha, nope,” he says, scanning the menu rather than looking at me. “I’m actually kinda between jobs.”
“Oh. I thought were a project manager at a tech startup?”
That’s what his profile had said, at any rate.
“Oh. I don’t do that anymore… I kind of, decided to leave the company. Or… I mean, they asked me to.”
“Why?”
He puts down his menu to give me a frustrated look.
“Do you know, they expect you to show up every day at nine?” he huffs. “Like, cut a guy a break, right? What if I get a flat tire or like… traffic’s bad, or whatever?”
“Oh. Um. Right. I guess.”
“Anyhow, if you don’t show up ‘on time’” – he air quotes the last two words – “They write you up or whatever and apparently that’s enough reason to fire you. It’s fucking bullshit, man.”
“Yeah, right. I guess so.” I lean over and sneak a peek at his footwear. Yup. Still flip-flops. I hadn’t imagined those. “Right. I mean, I should’ve figured you weren’t working today… It’s not like you could wear those shoes to work, huh?”
“Oh. These?”
He lifts up his foot and wiggles his toes to demonstrate the item in question. If there’s something on this planet that’s more gross than a dude’s feet, I have yet to discover it… These are a particularly grungy specimen. Almost completely gray, like a cross between stone and a rotting tree, with discolored toenails and some sort of fungus growing on the sole of the flop.
“I wear these everywhere,” he says. “All year round. Yup… no season too cold for flip flops for me.”
“Maybe there should be,” I mutter under my breath, desperately staring at the menu.
“What’s that, babe?”
“Nothing,” I say, attempting to paste the smile back on my face.
I’m grateful for small miracles as the waitress makes her appearance at our table. This is a nice enough restaurant. The wait staff wears black trousers with white button-down shirts. The name of the restaurant is embroidered on the cuff of her sleeve and the material of the shirt looks fine enough to be some sort of silk.
I gulp and swallow down a little shame as she eyes my date’s outfit. Honestly, I’m not sure how they let him in here… Isn’t this place black-tie only?
But she doesn’t say anything. Instead, she carefully pastes a smile on her face, not unlike my own, before speaking.
“Welcome to L’etoile,” she says, plastic smile firmly affixed. “Do you know what you would like or would you like some time to consider our menu?”
He slaps the multi-page menu shut with a decisive snap.
“We’ll each have a filet mignon, with twice-baked potatoes, and a couple of miller lites,” he says.
She must’ve been working here for a while because the expression on her face doesn’t falter.
“Very good, sir.”
As for me, the first thing that emerges from my mouth is an angry squawk, as my jaw drops open.
“Close your mouth, babe,” he says. “You look kinda dumb with your mouth hanging open like that.”
“I’m a vegetarian!”
My words come out in an angry hiss.
“Welp, I guess tonight, you’re not.”
“I hate beer.”
He rolls his eyes at me.
“You can’t drink soda at a classy place like this,” he tells me. “Besides, the light stuff is better for you… you should be watching your weight.”
Stay hopeful, I tell myself.
I also remind myself that my Mom has a date tonight, too, which helps… I’m more worried about interrupting her night than ruining my own. But I force myself to stay calm.
After all, there was a reason I liked this guy in the first place, right? I just need to focus on that, and I’ll be fine.
Thankfully, there isn’t too much time for the conversation to stall – the waitress is quick with our food and our – sigh – beer.
I am pleasantly surprised to find a larger than average portion of vegetables, and what appears to be a small quiche on my plate, and give her a grateful smile.
“So, babe, what do you do?” he asks.
I explain that I majored in Environmental Science – that I’d wanted to go to grad school and work in marine biology in California, but that the funds ran out and, well, that’s how I find myself here.
“Apparently, Chicago doesn’t need environmentalists,” I joke, finally. “But they do need waitresses.”
“Nobody needs environmentalists,” he says. “What a waste of space. Global warming is a pile of crap anyway.”
How tastefully put. I’d never heard anyone put down my entire education and career so succinctly.
I’m really focusing on glaring daggers at his stupid face when he chuckles.
“This food is amazing,” he says. “Can’t believe it’s free.”
“Free?”
“Oh, yeah,” he says. “My mom gave me this coupon. She says I need to get out more – I mean, she has to clean my room some time, and she can’t exactly do that while I’m in it. Seriously, though. A free steak dinner at l’etoile? Like I’m gonna pass that up. Super-fancy, man. Wish I could eat this crap every night.”
“You mean two dinners, don’t you?”
“Awww, man… No, I mean… We’re going dutch, right?” he says. “I thought you knew that.”
“I – yeah. Ummm… sure.”
I don’t have words. The grin on my face has become a rictus.
“If you’ll excuse me, I need to use the bathroom.”
“Cool, babe. Hey – don’t be too long.” He waggles his eyebrows. “I’ll miss you, ya know.”
I back away from the table, and go right out the door.
I told him I had to go to the bathroom – I just didn’t tell him I was going to the bathroom at home.
******
You know those empty-nesters who rekindle their relationship and fall sooooo much more in love after their kids go away to college?
Yeah… That wasn’t us.
Long story short: my husband is on a kibbutz in Israel, doing barely legal drugs and barely legal women, and my daughter is upstairs… Well, not literally upstairs.
But my husband moved out and my daughter moved back in.
So what do you do when you lose a husband and gain a crippling sense of inadequacy and a roommate into the bargain?
- Buy wine. Lots of wine.
- Invest in a good (and quiet!) vibrator.
- Invest in a high-quality pair of noise-canceling headphones (just because your vibrator is quiet, doesn’t mean hers is…)
- (Gulp)… join the dubious world of online dating.
It wasn’t exactly fun the first time, but… here we go again.
I’ve always believed in the power of a home-court advantage. With that in mind, I decided to invite my ‘match’ over for dinner. It didn’t hurt that Haley would be out on her own date.
I took a gulp of wine and started ticking off the reasons this wouldn’t work on my fingers.
- He could be a serial killer.
- Or a Trump supporter.
- He could have weird webbing between his toes
- Or B.O.
- Or all of the above.
I shake my head to clear out the negative thoughts. Negativity doesn’t help anything, I remind myself out loud the same way I’d say it to Haley.
Besides, it could be wonderful, couldn’t it?
His picture was cute
He appeared to be able to formulate complete sentences, punctuation and all.
He appeared sane, and employed and … well, normal.
So far, so good…
I lean over to check on my pizza.
He didn’t mention what he wanted for dinner, but… let’s be honest here, my pizza’s amazing. I make the dough myself.
My pizza has been known to resolve international crises. Ok…. well, maybe not international crises. But it did the trick whenever Halley was going through teenage drama, and I’ll tell you right now – teenage problems are a lot stickier to resolve than any international crisis.
I pull it out of the oven, pull together a quick salad, check my hair and my makeup, and put a smile on my face as I go to answer the door.
He looks… kind of like his picture. If you consider that the picture was probably taken 15 years and 50 pounds ago.
He definitely has a certain something that was lacking in his profile pic – and that something is a Hitler mustache, hanging on his lip like an angry caterpillar.
“Wow!” he says, immediately angling in for a hug. “You look even prettier than your picture!”
“Thanks,” I say, pulling away as quickly as I can. “You look… like your photo, too. But I don’t remember that mustache from your photos.”
“This thing?” he strokes it proudly. “Can you imagine that my ex-wife hated it? She said it was ‘offensive.’”
He air quotes the last word.
“How can hair be offensive?” he asks. “It’s just hair, right?”
I’m speechless as he walks past me and plonks himself down at the kitchen bar, where I’ve laid out pizza and salad, with homemade breadsticks and twin place settings.
He looks at the pizza like it’s something I snaked out of the drain.
“Pizza?” he says. “I thought I was coming over for a home-cooked meal.”
“It is home-cooked. I made the dough myself and everything.”
“Still,” he says. “Pizza? I mean, I could’ve just ordered pizza.”
He gives me a critical look and continues.
“My ex-wife – she would’ve made a real dinner. Baked potatoes and steak and ….”
I stop him before he can develop a full head of steam.
“Well, then,” I interject. “Why don’t you go back to your ex-wife?”
“There’s no need to be like that,” he says. “I was just pointing out that you could’ve done better, you know, if you’d tried… You’ll never catch a man with that attitude.”
“And I was just about to point out the door. Same one you came in through.”
“Well, if you’re going to be like that!” he huffs. “You’re certainly never going to find forever-love.”
“And I certainly don’t want ‘forever-love’ if it’s going to be with someone like you.”
I’ve only just sat down and poured myself a glass of wine when Halley comes home. She looks… well, she looks beautiful, in the red sweater dress that contrasts with her dark hair and makes her blue eyes pop. And she also looks like someone just kicked her puppy…. Until she sees the food.
“Omygosh!!! Pizza!!!”
“Yup,” I tell her. “My date didn’t appreciate it.”
She stares at me bug-eyed.
“Didn’t appreciate it?” Her jaw drops open. “Mom – your pizza could solve the crisis in the middle east.”
And don’t I know it.
“You wanna watch a movie?” I ask.
*****
It’s the middle of the night, when everything seems quiet. Even the sound from the tv is strangely muted.
We’re two Julia Roberts movies and 3/4 of a pizza in when Halley starts to nod. And we’re somewhere around the point that Julia is telling Dermot Mulroney about her fake engagement that Halley’s head drops onto my shoulder and her arms wrap around my waist.
I wrap my arm around her and she cuddles into me, just like she used to do when she was a little girl.
“Best date night ever,” she whispers, cuddling closer.
And that’s when I finally realize it…. I already have forever-love, although not the kind he was talking about. It is right here, next to me.
Yup. I agree. Best date night ever.